Welcome to Created, the newsletter that’s more satisfying than your laptop fan finally going quiet after a render. Here’s what we got today:
- Why the Try Guys shut down YouTube memberships
- World’s first VTuber school is here
- Outlier of the week
Top YouTubers Speak Out about YouTube's Paywall Feature
The Try Guys just shut down their YouTube memberships, the platform’s paywalled content, after fans complained that the member-only videos were clogging their feeds.
Instead, they’re moving exclusive content back to their standalone app, 2nd try.
But this isn’t just about one channel. It may signal a bigger trend on the platform.
What Happened
Originally, members-only videos lived in a separate tab.
Now?
YouTube pushes those paywalled videos into homepages, subscriptions feeds and recommendations.
Which means non-paying viewers constantly see thumbnails they can’t click.
The Try Guys said they didn’t realize how aggressively YouTube would distribute those videos — and they don’t control how it works.
Sound familiar?
The Try Guys aren’t alone:
Our Take
Creators want to decide how — and where — they promote paywalled content.
When that control shifts to the platform, the biggest creators simply move to alternative platforms (2nd try, Floatplane, Patreon).
The Try Guys and Linus aren’t anti-subscription.
They’re protecting the audience experience they built.
How Virtual YouTubers Make Millions in Japan...Is America Next?
Imagine your favorite high school teacher being a virtual influencer.
Well, that’s what’s happening in Japan right now.
The Tokyo-based tutoring company Luminaris has launched Wish High, Japan’s first online “cram school” where every teacher is a VTuber.
And yes, students pay real tuition.
Wait...What’s a “Cram School”?
In Japan, cram schools are private, after-school programs built around one thing: passing exams.
The market is already worth billions. Families pay extra — sometimes thousands per year — for intensive test prep outside regular school hours.
Wish High just moved that system online.
The difference? Every teacher is an animated avatar.
Why VTubers?
Online education has a retention problem.
Students click. Watch. Drop off.
Luminaris says many learners are “left behind without understanding.”
So they’re betting on something schools rarely optimize for: attention.
Live lessons. Creator-style delivery. VTubers students may already follow.
In short: combine parasocial internet culture with education.
Our Take
Wish High didn’t invent a new system. It plugged creator culture into an existing one.
The U.S. already has YouTube educators with millions of subscribers, paid cohort-based courses and creator-led bootcamps.
If this model sticks in Japan, don’t be surprised if creator-led schools start popping up closer to home.
The real question then is whether traditional schools can compete with creators who already know how to hold attention.
🎯 Weekly Roundup: Thumbnails
Why we love these YT thumbnails:
- Driver’s tense expression + 84mph stat makes it feel less like sport and more like survival (Jason Kelce)
- “Dopamine detox” over a lush, peaceful scene promises a reset your brain craves (Russell Wofford)
- Calling that tiny cube a “hotel” in the middle of nowhere demands explanation (Tonio Guajardo)
- Unzipping a shoe with “cheating?” frames performance gear as controversy (Isaiah Photo)
🚀 Weekly Outlier
This video by Dabby has 1.4M views, which is 30 times higher than the channel’s average. Here’s why it took off:
- Big Idea, Simple Frame: “You’re not what you eat, you’re what you absorb” reframes nutrition instantly.
- High-Speed Clarity: Explains dense science with punchy metaphors (“acid tank,” “biochemical scissors”).
- Problem → Solution Arc: Breaks down modern food traps, then delivers a simple 4-step fix.
🏆 The Created Referral Program
Know someone who’d also love this newsletter? Refer them and get gifts.
Refer 1 friend: you’ll get my Infinite Ideas book. It’s my 8 best tips to find viral ideas for your next upload.
Refer 5 friends: you’ll get my Top 50 Thumbnails book. It includes a detailed breakdown of why they work so you improve your packaging.
Trust me, these books are packed with more tips than most paid courses.
Copy this unique link and email, text, or post it: [RH_REFLINK GOES HERE]
👋 See You Inside
Join our Discord of 5,700 creators who help each other grow and give feedback on your ideas, videos, and thumbnails. Totally free.
Nothing great is created alone.
– Jon
Want to advertise with us? Go here.
Was this email forwarded to you? Join here.
Have a tip or story we should cover? Submit here.
